Get the app
Pythagoras on a hilltop path looking out over a whole coastal town

The main idea is rarely a sentence you can copy. It is what the whole paragraph adds up to. The test hides it among choices that are true but too small, or too big for the passage. The size rule sorts them in seconds.

15 min read · 2 sample questions · 11 flashcards · Free

The idea that covers the whole paragraph

Passage

In many cities, empty lots have been turned into community gardens. Neighbors who once passed each other without a word now share tools, swap seeds and trade advice about tomatoes. Some gardens give part of their harvest to food banks. A patch of soil, it seems, can grow more than vegetables.

Every sentence points the same way: the gardens bring people together and help the neighborhood. The last line sums it up with a picture: the gardens “grow” friendships and help for the neighborhood, not only vegetables. A good main idea: community gardens benefit neighborhoods in ways beyond food.

Key idea

Say it yourself before you look

Cover the choices and say in one sentence what the paragraph is about. Then pick the choice closest to yours. If you read the choices first, a true detail will pull you in.

Next: Learn

How to solve them

  1. 1

    The size rule: not too narrow, not too broad

    Most wrong choices are the wrong size. A choice about one sentence is too narrow. A choice about more than the passage discusses is too broad. The answer fits the whole paragraph exactly.

    Too narrow

    Neighbors swap seeds in community gardens.

    One detail

    Too broad

    The history of farming in America.

    Far bigger than the text

    Just right

    Community gardens help neighborhoods in many ways.

    Covers every sentence

    Next step: Where it sits
  2. 2

    Where the main idea usually sits

    Look hard at the first and last sentences: one of them often states or sums up the idea. The middle sentences are usually support: examples, reasons, details.

    Shortcut

    First and last

    Read the first sentence, then the last. If they agree, that is very likely your main idea. In the garden passage, the last line (“can grow more than vegetables”) sums it up.

    Next step: True but small
  3. 3

    The trap: a choice that is true but too small

    A detail from the passage is true, which makes it tempting. But a main idea question does not ask “what is true?” It asks “what is the whole thing about?”

    True, but too small

    Some gardens donate to food banks.

    In the text, but one sentence

    The question asks

    “mainly about”

    the whole paragraph

    Next step: Best title
  4. 4

    Best title questions are main idea questions

    A good title names the topic and hints at the point. Apply the same size rule.

    Weak title

    Tomatoes

    Too narrow

    Good title

    Gardens That Grow Neighborhoods

    Topic and point

    Next step: Topic vs point
  5. 5

    Topic versus point

    The topic is what the paragraph talks about (community gardens). The main idea is what it says about that topic (they help neighborhoods). Choices that only name the topic are often too vague.

    Topic only

    Community gardens.

    Says nothing about them

    Main idea

    Community gardens bring neighbors together.

    Topic + point

    Next step: Check
  6. 6

    Check: does every sentence support it?

    Run through the sentences: does each one support your choice? If one sentence has nothing to do with it, your choice is too narrow. If your choice talks about things no sentence mentions, it is too broad.

    Shortcut

    The umbrella test

    Picture your answer as an umbrella. Every sentence of the paragraph should fit under it, and nothing outside the paragraph should be under it.

    Next step: Three examples
  7. 7

    Three worked examples, from easy to test level

    Each one starts with the first try many people make, crossed out, and then the way that works. Read the wrong try too: the test puts that kind of answer in the choices.

    In all three, the steps are the same: say the idea yourself, check the size of each choice, and run the umbrella test before you pick.

    Example · Easy

    “Carpooling to work cuts what each person spends on gas. Riders can take turns driving, so no one gets too tired. Fewer cars on the road also means less traffic for everyone.” What is the main idea?

    First tryCarpooling saves money on gas

    1. Cover the choices and say it yourself: sharing rides helps in more than one way.
    2. Count the points: money (sentence one), less tiredness (sentence two), less traffic (sentence three). That is three benefits.
    3. The first try is true, but it only covers sentence one. It is too narrow.
    4. The answer has to hold all three benefits: carpooling has several benefits.

    Answer Carpooling has several benefits

    Example · Medium

    “Many people think a bigger TV is always better. However, a screen that is too big for a small room can tire your eyes and make the picture look grainy. The best size depends on how far you sit from the screen.” What is the main idea?

    First tryBigger TVs are always better

    1. Find the turn word: “However.” What comes after it is what the author really thinks. The first sentence is only the belief the author argues against.
    2. The first try copied that first sentence, so it says the opposite of the author’s point.
    3. Say it yourself: the right size depends on the room.
    4. Umbrella test: sentence two gives the problem with a screen that is too big, and sentence three gives the rule. Both fit under your idea.

    Answer The best TV size depends on the room and how far away you sit

    Example · Test level

    “Payday can feel like a lot of money, but it goes fast. Many new service members find that writing down every expense for one month shows where the money really goes. Small things, like snacks and food delivery, often add up to more than they expected. Once they see the pattern, saving gets much easier.” Which title fits best? Snacks Cost Money · Track Your Spending to Save More · Life on a Military Base · How Payday Works

    First trySnacks Cost Money

    1. Say the idea first: writing down what you spend helps you save.
    2. Size check: “Life on a Military Base” is far bigger than the passage, so it is too broad. “How Payday Works” is off topic: the passage never explains how pay works.
    3. The first try grabbed the most surprising line. Snacks are one example in one sentence, so that title is too narrow.
    4. Umbrella test: money goes fast, write it down, small things add up, saving gets easier. Every sentence fits under “Track Your Spending to Save More.”

    Answer Track Your Spending to Save More

Next: Watch out

4 traps in the answer choices

The test writes its wrong answers on purpose: each one is what you get if you make one of these mistakes.

Trap

A true detail

The garden passage is mainly about:

Wronggardens give food to food banks

Rightgardens help neighborhoods in many ways

Trap

Too broad

The garden passage is mainly about:

Wronghow cities are planned

Rightwhat community gardens do for neighbors

Trap

Just the topic

The garden passage is mainly about:

Wronggardens

Rightgardens that bring neighbors together

Trap

Reading the choices first

You see a true sentence among the choices:

Wrongit feels right, you mark it

Rightsay the idea yourself first

Next: Practice

Try 2 questions

Two sample questions on this topic. Pick an answer, then read why. All the practice for this topic is in the Study Hall.

On test day

On the computer test, Paragraph Comprehension has 10 questions that count toward your score, in 27 minutes: about 2 min 42 s each. On paper it is 15 questions in 13 minutes, about 52 seconds each. That is enough time to read the passage once with care, but not three times.

Main idea questions come in several forms: “mainly about,” “best title,” “main point” or “best summary.” They all ask the same thing, and the size rule answers all of them.

Practical tip: read the question first, so you know you are hunting for the big idea. Then read the passage and say the idea in your own words before you look at the choices. On the computer test you cannot go back to a question, so check your choice with the umbrella test before you move on.

Question 1 of 2 · Warm-up

Passage: “Walking twenty minutes a day can lower blood pressure, improve sleep and lift mood. It needs no equipment and no gym. For many people, it is the easiest healthy habit to start.” The main idea is that…

Show the answer

A. Every sentence supports one point: walking is good for you and easy to begin. Sleep is a single benefit, so that choice is too narrow. The passage never says gyms are expensive, and it says walking needs no equipment, so special shoes is wrong too. The answer is Walking is an easy habit with many health benefits.

Question 2 of 2 · Warm-up

Which title best fits the garden passage?

Show the answer

C. The title has to cover the whole idea: gardens and what they do for the people around them. Tomatoes is too narrow, Empty Lots is only the starting point, and the history of cities is too broad. The answer is What Community Gardens Give a Neighborhood.

The Study Hall

Practice this topic for real

The full lesson in the ASVABIFY Community: more practice questions with every answer explained, and a checkpoint that tells you when you have it. Reading is free with an account; all the practice comes with Study Hall Plus, and it is included with Pro.

Practice in the Study Hall Stuck on one? Ask in #questions, free
Next: Flashcards

11 flashcards

Tap a card to flip it. Keep the ones you miss until they stick.

11 cards
Lesson complete

You finished this lesson: Main idea questions.

Practice score: not taken yet Take the practice

Next topic: Inference Course map
In the app

See this topic move.

In the course, every topic is drawn step by step on a whiteboard while a voice explains it, with timed practice tests and a plan for your test date. The first lessons of every module are free.

Try the app free